The CIA and/or NSA lying to or even intimidating the US Congress should concern all Americans even if torture of terror suspects may not particularly trouble many. “Empowering the American people” as Senator John McCain emphasized was the most critical objective in the long awaited release of the US Senate’s CIA Torture Report. Even more than the sordid evidence of abuses and torture detailed in the Report, more troubling is the degree to which the US Congress and citizens were deceived as to the torture techniques employed and the efficacy of the operations. The higher priority appears to have been not only to rationalize but even extend the covert “rendition” programs and the so-called “Enhanced Interrogation Techniques” (EIT). Skeptics within the Government were silenced and those presumably mandated with oversight were effectively co-opted by acquiescence and/or complicity after the fact in order to salvage institutional narratives and reputation.
Disinformation, Lies & Videotapes!
Probably the most damning assessment came at the conclusion of Senator Dianne Feinstein’s, Chair of the Intelligence Committee, statement to the US Senate making public the Report after months, perhaps years of delay: “CIA does not want this Report coming out.” That is a disturbing statement on several levels but most critically because the Senate Intelligence Committee is one of the few bodies that is mandated to oversee on behalf of US citizens the secret activities by US security agencies.
Beyond the “conflicts of interest” and “avoidance of responsibility,” Senators Feinstein and McCain charged that the CIA employed “disinformation” at the highest level and with respect to the highest presumed authorities in the US system of governance. Senator Feinstein specifically cited a confidential but legally required briefing to the Senate Intelligence Committee by then CIA Chief John McLaughlin who assured the Senators in 2004 that: “Nothing like what was at Abu Ghraib” was being done by the CIA. In fact, the Report reveals as much or worse. In a reference to then Secretary of State, one secret communique also rationalized not fully briefing the other members of US Executive nor the US Congress by noting that “(Colin) Powell would blow his stack” if informed of the actions.
Rogue Operation Overseeing Itself?
Senator Feinstein cited not only financially juicy deals but persons of questionable credentials and character in not only managing but effectively establishing themselves as the sole oversight. Persons with “personal, professional & ethical problems” as well as a “history of violence” ran the CIA’s programs. Even those within the CIA including field officers most directly impacted by the program and its presumed valuable intelligence according to Senator Feinstein were “marginalized” and their concerns not reported beyond the walls of the Agency. Even the CIA’s own highest internal oversight officer, the Inspector General, was sidestepped in the review and the reports passed on to other presumably higher authorities in the US Government. The Senator noted that “Inaccurate memorandum were sent to the DOJ (US Department of Justice)”, further “what was described on paper did not match what was done in the blacksites” and in one particularly egregious action by CIA officials, video evidence of the EITs was destroyed before it could be called upon by either the US Congress or DOJ – a CIA official was alleged to have “lied” about the existence of such videos. Again, while the content of the videos as well as other evidence may have informed the US Congress, and by extension Americans, of the brutality and efficacy of the “program” what is most shocking is the brazen manner in which oversight was avoided, even undermined, including reviews by the DOJ and the lack of any action to sanction such obstruction of the law as well as the Senate’s own reviews.
Would McCain Presidency have been more Transparent & Demanding of Accountability?
The US Executive both under Presidents Obama as well as Bush appears to have been reluctant to demand accountability and/or pursue prosecutions for the legally sanctionable misdeeds. In fact as the CIA brass, the Obama Administration sought to keep the Report silent along with former Bush and CIA officials as well as some GOP Congress members. This contrasts to Republican Senator McCain (former Presidential Candidate and victim of torture in a Hanoi prison.) One has to wonder if the US would have been more forthcoming in closing Gitmo and/or cutting off questionable covert programs and abuses if McCain had been elected over Obama in 2008. Senator McCain spoke in pragmatic as well as ideological terms when he assured that the US “need not risk our national honor to prevail in this or any other war.” Perhaps though, this is a systemic problem pervasive through any Democratic or Republican Presidency, a virus deep within the software and hardware of a US system in which institutions first seek to rationalize their actions/inaction to self-preserve or expand, and particularly those who leverage their presumed value to US security against their critics?
Infecting Democracies with the Tactics of Rogue Regimes?
Established and newly aspiring democracies from Poland to Albania just liberated from authoritarian communism were drafted into the CIA’s EIT program as well as some of the globe’s most abusive dictatorial regimes. (See: “The Report on CIA Torture Confirms Our Worst Fears”) Bosnia & Herzegovina though stands out as a state both most vulnerable in its transition and in need of confirming the rule of law as part of the underpinnings of government. According to persons directly involved and as relayed to me, the presumed effort to capture war criminals as Ratko Mladic and Radovan Karadzic was in fact co-opted into the rendition and EIT programs soon after 9/11. Little effort was given to the stated mission of arresting the war criminals and the rule of law remained subservient to alternative agendas including nationalist rationalization for genocides and other war crimes committed in BiH. Those hiding war criminals, perhaps some themselves suspected of war crimes, became corroborators in the presumed war on terror. US leadership was undermined at a critical time when it was most needed by BiH citizens seeking out positive examples of democracy and governance at work. (See: “Construction According to Putin’s Model, from Bosnia to Europe?”)
A Personal Jihad?
Some have accused Senator Feinstein of waging a personal war in pressing for the release of the Report. Perhaps, as the interaction between the CIA and Senator’s staff became contentious. The Senator’s staff was even threatened by the charge of revealing national secrets, and in turn the Senator became offended, thankfully, more determined. Otherwise, would American citizens as well as accountability be empowered?
Senator McCain praised the “perseverance in the face of persistent obstacles” the work of the Senate Committee and its staff(s). Senator Feinstein noted the long history of the decade plus effort to deliver the Report, and in my view for some semblance of oversight and accountability to be finally realized. Those who sought to silence the Report countered with arguments of the success of the CIA’s efforts and understated the abusive tactics. They warned of dangers to national security if the Report were released.
Greatest Threat to America, System of Governance & Freedom from Within:
Regardless of efficacy, legality of the renditions and EIT under domestic and international law, the greatest threat to the US has been the lack of accountability, even arrogance of those who had assumed and/or usurped broad powers, including to be accountable to no one except some self-serving notion of patriotism. As Senator McCain noted, America is best when it acts in manner consistent with our democratic values: “we are better than those who would destroy us.”
It is fair though to ask, what would have occurred if one Republican and one Democratic Senator had not acted with personal conviction to get the Report out? The Bush III and Obama Administrations appear most inclined to seek silence and shovels to bury the past practices, legal or not, consistent with US Governance or not. The DOJ has prosecuted no one for some of the gravest violations of domestic and international law and most critically obstruction. (See: “UN Expert Calls for Prosecution of CIA, US Officials for Crimes Committed During Interrogations”)
On the other hand, whether WikiLeaks or Snowden, or whistle-blowers as Thomas Drake, there is a full court to prosecute and silence. (See: “Gang Rape of Free Media in Our Western Democracies?”)
It appears that even the Rule of Law has been applied, most selectively, and particularly in favor of institutional infallibility. Next time, and almost undoubtedly there will be, will we have more resolute Administrations or two more Senators from each party courageous and committed, or will America need a fictional character of super means, will and luck as from the “Bourne Legacy” to heroically expose such threat from within the system? Apologists will also fall back on draping themselves in the flag, or more accurately camouflaging. “Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel” is a most worthy reminder in reviewing the debates regarding the Report’s publication. It is a free media and citizens demanding transparency that defend the country and values that some others may be more exploiting for adornment or worse.
Ambassador Muhamed Sacirbey
Any brutality as well as war can be justified with the cry that “God is on our side.” That is also now the recruiting tool and justification for all that ISIS has done and before them Al-Qaeda. It cannot be the rationalization for what America does. One of my favorite songs persists in its relevance, from Bob Dylan to The Neville Brothers and here, Joan Baez:
PHOTO: Senator John McCain, POW/businessinsider.com
Pingback: viagra use()
Pingback: otc cialis()
Pingback: cialis price walmart()
Pingback: cialis coupon walmart()
Pingback: Viagra order()
Pingback: Usa pharmacy viagra()
Pingback: generic cialis()
Pingback: cialis generic()
Pingback: cialis canadian pharmacy()
Pingback: order cialis online()
Pingback: cialis price walmart()
Pingback: viagra 100mg()
Pingback: cheap viagra()
Pingback: ed pills gnc()
Pingback: best erectile dysfunction pills()
Pingback: male erection pills()
Pingback: best online pharmacy()
Pingback: pharmacy online()
Pingback: Viagra or cialis()
Pingback: cialis generic()
Pingback: order vardenafil()
Pingback: vardenafil price()
Pingback: levitra pills()
Pingback: doubleu casino online casino()
Pingback: real money casino()
Pingback: viagra pill()
Pingback: online slots()
Pingback: casino slots()
Pingback: generic cialis reviews()
Pingback: cash loan()
Pingback: personal loans()
Pingback: personal loan()
Pingback: new online casino no deposit bonus 2019()
Pingback: viagra cost()
Pingback: best sports gambling sites()
Pingback: online casino()
Pingback: online casino games()
Pingback: new cialis()
Pingback: hollywood casino online()
Pingback: cialis buy()
Pingback: generic cialis()
Pingback: buy cialis()
Pingback: cialis buy()
Pingback: hollywood casino()
Pingback: casino slot()
Pingback: real casino online()
Pingback: best casino online()
Pingback: online pharmacy viagra()
Pingback: non prescription viagra()
Pingback: viagra canada()
Pingback: viagra cost()
Pingback: buy viagra()
Pingback: purchase viagra()
Pingback: purchase cialis()
Pingback: online viagra()
Pingback: generic viagra()
Pingback: cheapest viagra 50 mg()
Pingback: viagra online usa()
Pingback: tadalafil dosage()
Pingback: viagra pills()
Pingback: medicines without a doctor prescription()
Pingback: cheapest viagra online()
Pingback: buy viagra without a prescription()
Pingback: chumba casino()
Pingback: real money casino()
Pingback: buy cheap viagra generic online()
Pingback: viagra coupons printable()
Pingback: buy levitra cialis viagra()
Pingback: where to buy viagra in canada()
Pingback: Viagra 130 mg over the counter()
Pingback: where can i buy Viagra 120 mg()
Pingback: Viagra 150mg australia()
Pingback: Viagra 50mg without a prescription()
Pingback: Viagra 100 mg united states()
Pingback: Viagra 200mg usa()
Pingback: Viagra 130mg pharmacy()
Pingback: viagra prices()
Pingback: Viagra 130 mg price()
Pingback: Cialis 10 mg tablets()
Pingback: Cialis 10mg pharmacy()
Pingback: Cialis 10mg united states()
Pingback: Cialis 60 mg over the counter()
Pingback: buy generic viagra()
Pingback: where to buy Cialis 60 mg()
Pingback: Cialis 60mg usa()
Pingback: Cialis 40mg uk()
Pingback: Cialis 60mg nz()
Pingback: rx trust pharm()
Pingback: lasix 40mg coupon()
Pingback: furosemide 100mg prices()
Pingback: lexapro 5 mg canada()
Pingback: abilify 10mg prices()
Pingback: actos 30 mg tablets()
Pingback: aldactone 25mg without a prescription()
Pingback: allegra 120 mg pharmacy()
Pingback: allopurinol 300mg united states()
Pingback: amaryl 2mg australia()
Pingback: order amoxicillin 250 mg()
Pingback: ampicillin 500mg coupon()
Pingback: order antabuse 500mg()
Pingback: aricept 5 mg prices()
Pingback: cialistodo.com()
Pingback: augmentin 875/125 mg medication()
Pingback: cheap avodart 0,5 mg()
Pingback: bactrim 800/160 mg nz()
Pingback: tadalafil tablets()
Pingback: how to buy benicar 40mg()
Pingback: cheapest Biaxin 250mg()
Pingback: Premarin 0,625mg generic()
Pingback: how to purchase calcium carbonate 500 mg()
Pingback: stendra vs viagra()
Pingback: cardizem 180mg canada()
Pingback: rxtrust pharm()
Pingback: casodex pharmacy()
Pingback: buy catapres 100 mcg()
Pingback: how to purchase ceclor()
Pingback: order celebrex 100mg()
Pingback: celexa pharmacy()
Pingback: rxtrustpharm()
Pingback: cephalexin generic()
Pingback: cipro 750 mg medication()
Pingback: claritin 10 mg uk()
Pingback: casino online real money()
Pingback: free slots online()
Pingback: casino slots()
Pingback: casino online games()
Pingback: casino online games()
Pingback: online slots real money()
Pingback: online casino games real money()
Pingback: parx casino online()
Pingback: virgin casino online nj login()
Pingback: best online casino for money()
Pingback: automobile insurance()
Pingback: abc car insurance()
Pingback: carinsurance()
Pingback: cheap car insurance quotes()
Pingback: erie car insurance quotes group()
Pingback: car insurance quotes texas online()
Pingback: nationwide car insurance quotes()
Pingback: car insurance quotes()
Pingback: freeway car insurance()
Pingback: where can i buy herbal viagra over the counter()
Pingback: personal loans memphis()
Pingback: small payday loans()
Pingback: payday loans pa()
Pingback: guaranteed installment loans()
Pingback: apply for quick loans online()
Pingback: what does viagra di()
Pingback: bad credit loans()
Pingback: payday loans()
Pingback: personal loans corinth ms()
Pingback: viagra cheap online()
Pingback: cbd oil benefits 2016 usa()
Pingback: cbd oil for pain reviews()
Pingback: cbd oil wholesale()
Pingback: best cbd oil for pain()
Pingback: sildenafil 25 mg tablet()
Pingback: viagra tablets uk()
Pingback: dosage of cbd oil for chronic pain()
Pingback: cbd oil for sale georgia()
Pingback: when will generic viagra()
Pingback: how much is real viagra()
Pingback: best cbd oil for pain for sale()
Pingback: cbd oil 300mg()
Pingback: Fda approved viagra()
Pingback: medical cannabis oil for sale high cbd rso()
Pingback: buy viagra online 100mg()
Pingback: viagra india()
Pingback: best custom essay writing service()
Pingback: buy an essays()
Pingback: writing essays services()
Pingback: are essay writing services legal()
Pingback: write a college essay()
Pingback: buying essays()
Pingback: french homework()
Pingback: generic viagra mastercard()
Pingback: essay writer online()
Pingback: buy custom essays online()
Pingback: cleocin usa()
Pingback: clomid 50mg without prescription()
Pingback: clonidine 0,1 mg canada()
Pingback: buy sildenafil generic canada()
Pingback: buy clozaril 25mg()
Pingback: Real viagra pharmacy prescription()
Pingback: colchicine 0,5mg over the counter()
Pingback: how to buy symbicort inhaler()
Pingback: combivent coupon()
Pingback: coreg without prescription()
Pingback: compazine 5mg prices()
Pingback: generic cialis()
Pingback: coumadin nz()
Pingback: Canada viagra()
Pingback: cozaar no prescription()
Pingback: crestor 20 mg usa()
Pingback: online essay writing help()
Pingback: cymbalta united states()
Pingback: cheap custom essay papers()
Pingback: dissertation writing services uk()
Pingback: original essay writing service()
Pingback: who will write my paper for me()
Pingback: dapsone 1000caps australia()
Pingback: thesis research()
Pingback: thesis proposal example()
Pingback: i want to buy a research paper()
Pingback: ddavp united states()
Pingback: order depakote 125mg()
Pingback: diamox without a doctor prescription()
Pingback: differin 15g australia()
Pingback: diltiazem online pharmacy()
Pingback: doxycycline 100 mg tablets()
Pingback: Buy viagra no prescription required()
Pingback: dramamine otc()
Pingback: order elavil 25mg()
Pingback: erythromycin tablet()
Pingback: etodolac 400 mg online()
Pingback: how to purchase flomax 0,2mg()
Pingback: cheap flonase nasal spray()
Pingback: garcinia cambogia 100caps generic()
Pingback: cheap geodon()
Pingback: cheap custom essays online()
Pingback: hyzaar 12,5mg uk()
Pingback: imdur united kingdom()
Pingback: cialis for sale()
Pingback: imitrex australia()
Pingback: go right here()
Pingback: imuran over the counter()
Pingback: indocin 75 mg purchase()
Pingback: lamisil 250 mg for sale()
Pingback: levaquin purchase()
Pingback: lopid 300 mg no prescription()
Pingback: buy lopressor 50 mg()
Pingback: luvox 100mg canada()
Pingback: macrobid online pharmacy()
Pingback: meclizine for sale()
Pingback: buy mestinon()
Pingback: micardis 20mg nz()
Pingback: how to buy mobic 15 mg()
Pingback: Kamagra Polo()
Pingback: order motrin()
Pingback: pharmacies()
Pingback: nortriptyline 25mg over the counter()
Pingback: periactin 4mg without a prescription()
Pingback: buy phenergan()
Pingback: where to buy plaquenil()
Pingback: prednisolone 40 mg without a doctor prescription()
Pingback: prevacid united kingdom()
Pingback: prilosec without a doctor prescription()
Pingback: proair inhaler australia()
Pingback: procardia 30mg pharmacy()
Pingback: proscar united kingdom()
Pingback: how to buy protonix 40 mg()
Pingback: how to buy provigil()
Pingback: cost of pulmicort()
Pingback: pyridium usa()
Pingback: reglan united kingdom()
Pingback: buy remeron 15mg()
Pingback: retin-a cream without a doctor prescription()
Pingback: revatio 20 mg canada()
Pingback: risperdal canada()
Pingback: how to purchase robaxin()
Pingback: cheapest rogaine()
Pingback: seroquel online pharmacy()
Pingback: order singulair 10mg()
Pingback: cheapest skelaxin()
Pingback: spiriva 9mcg without prescription()
Pingback: tenormin tablets()
Pingback: thorazine prices()
Pingback: toprol coupon()
Pingback: tricor canada()
Pingback: valtrex uk()
Pingback: verapamil 120 mg uk()
Pingback: cheap voltaren 100mg()
Pingback: wellbutrin for sale()
Pingback: zanaflex united kingdom()
Pingback: more helpful hints()
Pingback: zocor 20 mg usa()
Pingback: zovirax purchase()
Pingback: zyloprim 100 mg coupon()
Pingback: where can i buy zyprexa()
Pingback: zyvox online()
Pingback: sildenafil united kingdom()
Pingback: cheap tadalafil()
Pingback: furosemide australia()
Pingback: escitalopram canada()
Pingback: aripiprazole pills()
Pingback: pioglitazone medication()
Pingback: spironolactone 25mg without a prescription()
Pingback: how to buy fexofenadine 120 mg()
Pingback: glimepiride generic()
Pingback: meclizine no prescription()
Pingback: how to buy leflunomide()
Pingback: atomoxetine 25 mg usa()
Pingback: donepezil 10mg tablet()
Pingback: anastrozole pharmacy()
Pingback: irbesartan pills()
Pingback: dutasteride 0,5 mg online()
Pingback: olmesartan 40 mg no prescription()
Pingback: buspirone 10mg united states()
Pingback: clonidine 0.1 mg otc()
Pingback: cheap cefuroxime()
Pingback: celecoxib 200 mg online pharmacy()
Pingback: citalopram nz()
Pingback: cialis with dapoxetine overnite()
Pingback: cephalexin 500 mg pills()
Pingback: buy cialis online()
Pingback: ciprofloxacin 1000 mg pharmacy()
Pingback: loratadine price()
Pingback: brand cialis in the us()
Pingback: clindamycin united states()
Pingback: cost of clozapine()
Pingback: buy prochlorperazine 5mg()
Pingback: cialis to buy()
Pingback: carvedilolmg canada()
Pingback: warfarin 2mg australia()
Pingback: rosuvastatin 10 mg nz()